It's that time of year again.
Those of us who review film, TV, video games, or whatever can possibly
be reviewed, look back on the last 12 months and try to pick their
favorites. Again, we're asked a direct question that can be hard to
answer: Was it a GOOD year? I'll say this: It was better than 2014, a
year of growing pains for the next-gen systems. I'll also say this: Not
really. The year started strongly with some must-play titles releasing
in the first six months, but most of the year-end titles disappointed to
varying degrees. Yes, a few of those titles are on the list below, but
they never really competed with the top two titles for Game of the Year
like we hoped they would. And a few of the year-end titles ("Star Wars:
Battlefront," "Rainbow Six: Siege," "Assassin's Creed Syndicate") were
straight-up disappointments. Let's think positively. Let's hope 2016
starts as strong as 2015 did and keeps it up from there. And let's
celebrate the year that was with its ten best games.
Runner-ups (alphabetical): "Assassin's Creed: Syndicate," "Battlefield Hardline," "Just Cause 3," "LEGO Dimensions," "LEGO Jurassic World," "Life is Strange," "Madden NFL 16," "Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain," "NBA 2K16," and "Wolfenstein: The New Order"
Runner-ups (alphabetical): "Assassin's Creed: Syndicate," "Battlefield Hardline," "Just Cause 3," "LEGO Dimensions," "LEGO Jurassic World," "Life is Strange," "Madden NFL 16," "Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain," "NBA 2K16," and "Wolfenstein: The New Order"
10. "The Order: 1886"
Yes, it's too short. Yes, it's repetitive. I agree. So, why did it make this list? It's this simple: Very few games this year excelled at world-building. When I play a narratively strong game like this, I want to enter a different world. Think of Rapture in "Bioshock" or the universe of the "Mass Effect" games. The world of "The Order" is fully-realized and immersive. In fact, it's disappointing that we never saw DLC for it and that the game has been poorly received to the degree that a sequel is unlikely. Never say never.
9. "Guitar Hero Live"
I would have wagered that "Rock Band 4" would have been the more creatively vibrant of the two music games released this year. I would have been wrong. While "Rock Band 4" is undeniably fun, it is also undeniably a retread of what the franchise has done before. In fact, it's almost impossible to differentiate from "Rock Band 3." It's not unlike a remastered last-gen game now available on the next-gen. On the other hand, the people behind "Guitar Hero Live" considered what the PS4 can do that the PS3 cannot, and offered a unique experience with live performers instead of animated ones and streaming music channels to play along with. I'm not convinced the new fret system is superior to the old one, but "Guitar Hero Live" took a dead franchise and rebuilt it from the ground up instead of just reviving it.
8. "Game of Thrones"
Telltale Games is arguably the most important video game company working today. They have two games on this list and I'd call both must-plays. At times, this was the superior of their two 2015 offerings, but the end left enough cliffhangers and question marks to drop it to 2nd place and a few spots down this list. It's still an incredibly satisfying piece of storytelling, a game that doesn't just recreate what works about the George R. R. Martin books and HBO shows as much as it is feels like another chapter in this multi-character tale. The decisions forced upon you in "Game of Thrones" are some of the most memorable in any game this year. Most often, there's not a "good" choice to make--just bad and worse.
7. "Call of Duty: Black Ops III"
Another year, another "CoD." I totally get many gamer's exhaustion with this franchise, one that doesn't take enough creative risks, especially when it comes to map design, and I'm not here to proclaim "Black Ops III" as the breakthrough in multiplayer gameplay that Activision touted it as being. All I'll say is that "Black Ops III" remembered to be something that too few multiplayer games were in 2015: fun. With the addition of new specialists and their unique weapons, "Black Ops III" delivered the most robust multiplayer game of the year. It's the one I've gone back to the most, and I can't wait to see what the map packs bring. I still think these games fall just short of their potential, especially in the campaigns, but for sheer playing time value, I'd be dishonest if this wasn't on the list.
6. "Fallout 4"
Speaking of playing time, it's easy to plug dozens of hours into this excellent RPG, and that's just time spent looking at your inventory. My experience with "Fallout 4" has been an exercise in the scales of video game justice. On one side of the scale, there is the sheer scope of this game, one of the most impressive worlds of the year, and the emotional gravity of the main story. On the other side, balancing it out, is the repetitive combat, dull crafting, and unacceptable degree of glitchiness. Every time I felt like "Fallout 4" was going to transcend its flaws and become an honest GOTY contender, something would annoy me. Still, it's an incredibly enjoyable experience, the kind that can really drain your time. Especially when you spend two hours looking at your inventory.
5. "Until Dawn"
In 2015, after three decades of gaming, I'm mostly looking for video game experiences that feel unique, that redefine the way I play games. Is "Until Dawn" as ambitious as "Fallout 4" or even "Black Ops III"? Hell no. But I enjoyed every single second of it because it felt like something I wasn't used to playing in today's market. That's something that a lot of people forget about video game critics. We play almost everything. And so a truly strange title like "Until Dawn," which is essentially a hybrid of "Heavy Rain" and "Scream," stands out more. It helps that I'm a big horror fan, catching many of the references made by Larry Fessenden and his crew. I would absolutely love it if enough people played "Until Dawn" to inspire sequels and copycats. We need more games that expand what we expect when we hold a controller in our hands.
4. "Batman: Arkham Knight"
I know. I contradict myself. While most of the best games of the year expand the language of their form, sometimes you just want an old-fashioned action game done right. Enter the folks at Rocksteady and the best pure action game of the year. I played almost every minute of "Arkham Knight," save for a few Riddler trophies still circulating around town. And I enjoyed almost every minute of it (save for some of the tank missions perhaps). The narrative of "Knight" really gets what makes a great Batman game work. It incorporates a number of major and minor DC characters, and the way The Joker has been reimagined as a crazy devil on Bruce Wayne's shoulder is hilarious and truly insightful into what makes the Dark Knight tick.
3. "Tales From the Borderlands"
Telltale Games revolutionized the downloadable title with "The Walking Dead" but 2015 saw them top their greatest achievement to date with this amazing sci-fi/comedy/action/adventure. At first, I kind of just presumed that "Tales" would preach to the converted, working as a playful adventure for fans of 2K's "Borderlands" franchise (of which I am undeniably one). I was wrong. "Tales From the Borderlands" stands completely on its own, whether you've ever even played a "Borderlands" game or if you hate one. The storytelling here actually most recalls Joss Whedon's "Firefly" in its blend of comedy and space action. And then, out of nowhere, it gets actually moving. I'll miss these characters more than any others from 2015.
2. "The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt"
In terms of world creation, nothing in 2015 comes close to "The Witcher 3," the year's best RPG. The characters and narrative of "Wild Hunt" are strong enough to earn the game a spot on this list, but it competes for GOTY for another reason: more than any title this year, I felt like I was a small part of the universe of this game. I felt like NPCs were living their own lives and that danger lurked around any corner. Deep into the game, "The Witcher 3" has new things to show you, new worlds to explore, new enemies to fight, and new allies to make. It is as dense and complex as your favorite fantasy fiction, complete with fantastic combat and inventory mechanics to boot. It's one of the best games of the '10s.
EmoticonEmoticon